Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) to be Completed for Woodland Creation Proposals in 2025

Due to the sensitivity and complexity of certain aspects of the area, an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) is required to assess the impact, including beneficial, on some key sensitive areas such as the Upper Tweed National Scenic Area and the River Tweed Site of Special Scientific Interest / Special Area of Conservation. The EIA process is mandated by the Forestry (Environmental Impact Assessment) (Scotland) Regulations 2017 and includes targeted consultation with statutory bodies, including Scottish Forestry, NatureScot, the Scottish Environment Protection Agency (SEPA) and Historic Environment Scotland (HES) to identify and assess potential significant impacts. We anticipate completing the EIA in the autumn of 2025, at which time we will provide a further update on our progress including the publication of the EIA report.

Throughout this process, we have navigated complex ecological, environmental, and social considerations, and community input has been essential in helping us address these challenges thoughtfully. We continue to encourage those interested to get in touch with questions and comments using the ‘Get in Touch’ form on our Updates page, or to email info@stobohopeforest.co.uk

Get in touch

If you’d like to contact us regarding our plans for Stobo Hope Forest please feel free to complete the form below and we’ll take your comments into consideration.


17 April 2025

Scoping Meeting Presentation Slides

Following on from the Scoping meeting please find the surveys that were submitted for the original EIA Screening Opinion Request:

10 April 2025

The agenda for the EIA Scoping Meeting on April 15th will follow the standard format as outlined in appendix 1 of Scottish Forestry’s guidance:

Undertaking an Environmental Impact Assessment in Forestry 2022 (7).pdf

Stobo woodland creation EIA forestry project

Scoping meeting 15 April 2025

Chair: Cameron Maxwell, Head of Woodland Creation and Regulation, Scottish Forestry

 Agenda

1.    Introduction, apologies, purpose and content of the meeting

2.    Background and outline of proposals by the applicant

3.    Raising of relevant issues and concerns by each participant

4.    Correspondence in absentia

5.    Summary and close

20 March 2025

Under the EIA regulations, an invite only EIA Scoping Meeting will be taking place with statutory and local stakeholders in attendance. The following stakeholders have been invited:

  • NatureScot

  • Scottish Environmental Protection Agency

  • Scottish Borders Council

  • Historic Environment Scotland

  • Rural Payments and Services

  • Scottish Water

  • RSPB



  • Manor, Stobo, and Lyne Community Council

  • Tweed Forum

  • Stobo Residents Action Group

  • Timber Transport Forum

  • South Scotland Golden Eagle Project

  • Borders Deer Management Group

  • Immediate Neighbours

  • Local Community Representatives

Issues Log (2024)

  • Upper Tweed Community Council

  • Lothian and Borders Raptor Study Group

  • Butterfly Conservation Trust

  • Lothian and Borders Ramblers Group

  • Southern Upland Partnership

  • Centre for Ecology and Hydrology

  • Industry Representatives


17 Mar 2025

2025 Survey Boundary Map

A new set of ecological surveys commissioned for the Environmental Impact Assessment. These include: 

  • All areas identified as having known black grouse lek potential will be surveyed (Following the methods of Gilbert et al 2011). In addition to known lek areas, other areas of the estate with suitable lek habitat (woodland edges, rush pasture mosaics etc) will be surveyed to identify additional lek locations. Known leks and all areas of suitable lek habitat will be visited up to twice between mid-March and May surveying from one hour before sunrise to one hour after sunrise to count the peak number of males present.

  • A breeding bird survey will be undertaken across all open areas of the estate and a buffer out to 500m, where accessible.Method will follow that of an adapted Brown and Shepherd (1993) and Breeding Bird Survey methodology (BTO, 2003); all areas of the site will be walked to within 100m and all birds and behaviours will be mapped. Up to 6 visits will be undertaken between April-July (inclusive). All registrations recorded will be input to GIS software and analysed using the methods of Calladine et al (2009) to estimate the number of likely territories present.

  • Habitats will be recorded as per the Phase 1 Habitat Methodology (JNCC, 2016). The Phase 1 Survey documents habitats to a recognised standard and also records any stands of invasive non-native plants. This level of survey allows for the broad habitat types to be mapped in order to identify potentially sensitive habitats such as wetland areas which may have GWDTE potential or areas of habitat which may qualify as EC Annex 1 habitats (at time of UK exit).Aerial imagery will be consulted and overlain on top of the Site boundary. Visible habitat extend will be mapped in GIS software and surveyed in the field assigning Phase 1 codes to each habitat. Habitat condition sheets as per UKHab V2 (2023) will also be recorded.

  • Following identification of the broad habitats across the site as noted above, further vegetation survey will be undertaken to map habitats as per the National Vegetation Classification (JNCC, 2006). Reference will be made to ‘British Plant Communities’ Volumes 1-3, (Rodwell, 1991, 1991 & 1997,) and an ‘Illustrated Guide to British Upland Vegetation’ (Averis, 2004).

  • Following the NVC survey, all habitats with a potential reliance on a ground water sources, as defined by SEPAs Guidance note 31, will be mapped and assigned a GWDTE dependency rating of high, moderate or low. Where high and moderate potential GWDTE are present, a hydrogeological analysis will be undertaken to identify the water supply mechanism for each habitat and confirm

  • A protected species survey will be undertaken to identify signs indicating the presence or likely presence of protected and notable species, including; otter, badger, pine marten, red squirrel and water vole. Given the location of the site it is assumed wildcat and beaver are not likely to be present. Field signs such as footprints, feeding remains, places of shelter, scat etc will be recorded. Where field signs indicate the likely presence of protected species, additional works may be required to fully assess the species use of the site (such as camera trapping a badger sett to determine levels of activity)

  • A cumulative impact assessment will be undertaken taking into consideration the potential impacts of the proposed woodland scheme in conjunction with neighbouring projects. Consideration will be made to both potential negative and positive impacts from the developments